You look at someone likr Marcel Dionne who was number 2 in points fir a long time never win a cup no one mentions him as one of the greats. If Macdavid doesnt win a cup over time its possible the same would happen to him
The GOAT in hockey is The Great One. McDavid is a very skilled player but he ainât no Gretzky. Until he breaks Gretzkyâs records in points per game, Stanley Cup rings and overall points, goals and assists, he will always be âone of the greatest players in the history of the NHLâ but not the Greatest.
McDavid is a unidimensional player, only offense, his defensive play is very poor, unless he learns to play a good 200 foot game, he won't win a Stanley cup, Crosby is a more complete player than him, even Draisaitl is.
Itâll def be tarnished , doesnât matter if he breaks more records and rewrites the history books. If he doesnât hoist Lord Stanley thatâs whatâll we be remembered.
Holy Christ itâs not live Ovi didnât take 15 years to win a cup and I donât remember hearing him being called out the same way. Also ask them if Price has a tarnished rep I bet you theyâd say no. Winning is hard.
21 Comments
The new hockey fans call unproven players goats , it's a sad existence to live in
Mcdavid is the first player in THIRTY YEARS to score 150 points. Oilers are a goalie away from winning a cup
You look at someone likr Marcel Dionne who was number 2 in points fir a long time never win a cup no one mentions him as one of the greats. If Macdavid doesnt win a cup over time its possible the same would happen to him
100 percent tarnished if he donât win at a least 1
What's up with all of these 20 somethings dismissing the legitimate GOATS like Gretzky and Jordan.
not the goat
Couldn't have said it better myself
McDavid is no where near Gretzky are people losing there minds these new schoolers are ridiculous
Gretzky will always be the greatest, what are they talking about?
The GOAT in hockey is The Great One. McDavid is a very skilled player but he ainât no Gretzky. Until he breaks Gretzkyâs records in points per game, Stanley Cup rings and overall points, goals and assists, he will always be âone of the greatest players in the history of the NHLâ but not the Greatest.
McDavid is a unidimensional player, only offense, his defensive play is very poor, unless he learns to play a good 200 foot game, he won't win a Stanley cup, Crosby is a more complete player than him, even Draisaitl is.
Itâll def be tarnished , doesnât matter if he breaks more records and rewrites the history books.
If he doesnât hoist Lord Stanley thatâs whatâll we be remembered.
Yes. He NEEDS at least one Cup
Holy Christ itâs not live Ovi didnât take 15 years to win a cup and I donât remember hearing him being called out the same way. Also ask them if Price has a tarnished rep I bet you theyâd say no. Winning is hard.
Gretzky. Lemieux. Crosby. Ovechkin.
Did he just call McDavid the greatest hockey player of all time?
Give your balls a tug kid. Thatâs Wayne Gretzky. It will always be Wayne Gretzky.
#99EnoughSaid
Wonât happen with Gary boy in office
Get the man a goalie and respectable defense already….
No cup, no GOAT.
Crosby! Greatest player to ever play the game