I like both right gives more rugged classic hockey vibes, left gives more clean look a more modern hockey vibe.
IdyllicOleander
The one on the left always looked better to me.
Bearded_Poutine
Depends on their colour scheme. For these colours I like old better, but if it’s their 2009 era colour scheme I like the new logo better.
FormerCollegeDJ
The old/new logo on the right is much better.
chimpsimulator
Robo Penguin supremecy
BubbaSpanks
The right! Hockey penguin is a beast!
Fox33__
Old is classic and timeless, the “new” logo is too much of a 90s design and also associated with a team ownership who almost ruined the Penguins.
HanSolo5643
Both are great but it’s the new one.
ShitHouseMcTits
Honestly both are good
MotorFine7589
A a Penguins fan for 2 years, the old logo 100%. It’s sooooo much better, sleeker, and hockeyer (if that makes sense)
PhilG1989
Old
IsstvanIII
Old, but both are great
GlitteredRoomForView
Neither, the correct answer is the old “old” logo when the penguin was wearing a scarf too
iamjoe1994
My wife says right one because he has cute skates on.
DanTreview
OP, you can play this all day long if you want, but given that the average age of a typical Redditor is between 26 and 41, and that most people gravitate to the logos of their formative years, whatever was used in the 90s is going to win out, no matter the team, by and large.
Also, you forgot the poll buttons.
Last-Faithlessness-6
The left one gives me “Mario Lemieux is going to skate through your whole fucking team and score and there’s nothing you can do about it. Oh you wanna hold onto him for dear life with your stick? He’ll drag your fucking ass to the net and score anyways.” vibes.
So I vote left.
hockeyguy26er
The new old logo on the right is better.
petetheheat475
I really love the old one, but the new one is really sleek and doesn’t change too much to make me hate it. I’d prefer they keep the old logo, but I’d except the new one. But I’m also a Coyotes fan, so oh well.
JoshTheKid87
I like both even though I wasn’t around yet when the Robo Pen first came out.
Calico_furqueen
I just like the right one better. I didn’t get into hockey until 93 and therefore all my stuff back then had the left one…but I always secretly liked the right better and was happy when they went back.
JasonPlattMusic34
I love the Robo Penguin. But I know the Pens will never go back to it.
TenormanTears
old for me
DCASP500
Old
GrandpaMofo
Leave the Skating Penguin alone!
TiredReader87
Old logo
piantissimofan00
I think the robo penguin is one of the most overrated logos ever. I just don’t see it. The right one is so classic
Pebian_Jay
Old
quarrelsome_napkin
Old. I love the Canadian Tire Penguin!
ConstructionOk765
Both I love
EvetsYenoham
Every logo they’ve had is pretty dope. But I prefer the classic on the right. Background is golden triangle, a nickname for the burgh. And his focused eyeball is an “h” for hockey or maybe hornets, which was the AHL team until ‘67, or both. Also the jersey for this scene that could be in Shoresy…
New. They won all their cups under the skating penguin.
T-A-C-K-K
Old, it is so stylish and badass and much more intimidating
Wafflemonster2
Left one is vastly superior in most ways imo, but I do love the one on the right. Left one is one of the greatest NHL logos in general, I’ve always loved it
Buttercupia
Right. Though I like the really old logo where the penguin is wearing a scarf even better.
Fit_Use9941
New for sure
pikadoof87
I don’t care for the pigeon logo. I couldn’t stand when they brought it back.
LukeyMagukey
Old
Marckthesilver13
Honestly I like the old logo!
karlou1984
As.someone who despises the penguins, both logos are mint.
43 Comments
old
I like both right gives more rugged classic hockey vibes, left gives more clean look a more modern hockey vibe.
The one on the left always looked better to me.
Depends on their colour scheme. For these colours I like old better, but if it’s their 2009 era colour scheme I like the new logo better.
The old/new logo on the right is much better.
Robo Penguin supremecy
The right! Hockey penguin is a beast!
Old is classic and timeless, the “new” logo is too much of a 90s design and also associated with a team ownership who almost ruined the Penguins.
Both are great but it’s the new one.
Honestly both are good
A a Penguins fan for 2 years, the old logo 100%. It’s sooooo much better, sleeker, and hockeyer (if that makes sense)
Old
Old, but both are great
Neither, the correct answer is the old “old” logo when the penguin was wearing a scarf too
My wife says right one because he has cute skates on.
OP, you can play this all day long if you want, but given that the average age of a typical Redditor is between 26 and 41, and that most people gravitate to the logos of their formative years, whatever was used in the 90s is going to win out, no matter the team, by and large.
Also, you forgot the poll buttons.
The left one gives me “Mario Lemieux is going to skate through your whole fucking team and score and there’s nothing you can do about it. Oh you wanna hold onto him for dear life with your stick? He’ll drag your fucking ass to the net and score anyways.” vibes.
So I vote left.
The new old logo on the right is better.
I really love the old one, but the new one is really sleek and doesn’t change too much to make me hate it. I’d prefer they keep the old logo, but I’d except the new one. But I’m also a Coyotes fan, so oh well.
I like both even though I wasn’t around yet when the Robo Pen first came out.
I just like the right one better. I didn’t get into hockey until 93 and therefore all my stuff back then had the left one…but I always secretly liked the right better and was happy when they went back.
I love the Robo Penguin. But I know the Pens will never go back to it.
old for me
Old
Leave the Skating Penguin alone!
Old logo
I think the robo penguin is one of the most overrated logos ever. I just don’t see it. The right one is so classic
Old
Old. I love the Canadian Tire Penguin!
Both I love
Every logo they’ve had is pretty dope. But I prefer the classic on the right. Background is golden triangle, a nickname for the burgh. And his focused eyeball is an “h” for hockey or maybe hornets, which was the AHL team until ‘67, or both. Also the jersey for this scene that could be in Shoresy…
https://youtu.be/p3OexsI-KjA
Old
New. They won all their cups under the skating penguin.
Old, it is so stylish and badass and much more intimidating
Left one is vastly superior in most ways imo, but I do love the one on the right. Left one is one of the greatest NHL logos in general, I’ve always loved it
Right. Though I like the really old logo where the penguin is wearing a scarf even better.
New for sure
I don’t care for the pigeon logo. I couldn’t stand when they brought it back.
Old
Honestly I like the old logo!
As.someone who despises the penguins, both logos are mint.
Old logo.
Old