Prime Karlsson, he could dominate the ice every time he was on.
Rain-41
This last year offensive wise EK65 (non-biased I swear), he was getting a ton of assists and goals.
Massive-Spread-8381
Foxy
CitizenNaab
Cale. He’s so good at every facet of the game
Incognito1989
All hail Cale
931634
Cale.
starkmone
it’s makar by a trillion miles in my eyes
BoogerSlime666
Karlsson for all time Makar for right now
lmaoimmagetbanagain
makar. for the next 10 years the answer will be the same.
UnfairEntrepreneur80
Duncan Keith 😎🤣
Hungry_Definition450
Makar and it’s not close. Expect a healthy and extremely motivated Avalanche squad this next season.
MrWillM
Jacob Slavin
alecsharks
Karlsson if we’re comparing each player during their prime.
Makar for right now only
MichealangeloRetardo
“Get you outta my dreams get into Makar” – Billy Ocean
Arfguy
I say Erik Karlsson.
ubcthrowaway-01
Snuck Matthew Tkachuk in there
Canopus429
Miro is lockdown
hurricanesznsover
As a Stars fan, and someone relatively new to hockey, I know Miro is a star and one do the top players at his position. What makes Makar better or a lot better than him? Just curious.
And how would you rank Miro among defensemen and entire league?
GrouchoFartz
Chuck Norris
jordynbebus8
Fox is underrated… but Makar still gets my vote.
Miro deserves some love too
DivClassLg
Adam Fox
Really
really
Rowdy_Roddy96
The disrespect on Roman Josi is unreal rn. Dude had 96pts in 80Gms in the 2021/2022 season
Time-Dot5984
Love Hughes but it’s Makar
jeffroavs
Makar is just a notch above the pack. He’s elite at everything plus he’s super young, humble and hungry. His potential is the greatest of all time and he’s on pace to make it feasible.
CDL112281
Erik Karlsson.
JRR04
Here in Makar, I feel safest of all. I can lock all my doors. It’s the only way to live, Makar.
vlei90
Makar!
2BFrank69
Makar but Hughes is underrated
MechanismOfDecay
No one hurt me, but shouldn’t Dahlin be in this conversation? Too young?
4RealMy1stAcct
No love for Drew Doughty? WTF??!??
EyeHeartBidets
Jacob Slavin. Fucking Warrior.
magicandfire
Jaccob Slavin
SoakedNuts
Why tf is fox on this list?
AioliFantastic4105
The answer is obviously John Klingberg
SchattenjagerMosely
Josi
hammock8719
Still crazy to me that Philly passed on Makar but I’m not a scout.
imaybeacatIRl
Makar
Not being hyperbolic but Makar is the 2nd best player in the league behind McDavid.
HawtPackage
No Rasmussen Dahlin is just offensive.
HockeyShark91
Makar…. Karlsson is awesome when he’s not being a lazy ass. Played great this year hoping for a trade.
Eproxeri
Makar by a mile. But maybe surprisingly for many, I’d take Heiskanen second out of this list. Kids a stud and actually knows how to defend aswell.
PetterssonsNeck
It has to be my favourite movie, “Dude Where’s Makar”
No_Calligrapher7120
Seems to be a unanimous decision. Makar by a mile
Calling__Elvis
Niklas Lidstrom. You don’t need the “When healthy” on that one btw.
Tucxy
Makar
IamLiterallyAHuman
Makar and it’s not close.
theKindKitten
I don’t think anyone in this sub has actually watched Dahlin play
46 Comments
Prime Karlsson, he could dominate the ice every time he was on.
This last year offensive wise EK65 (non-biased I swear), he was getting a ton of assists and goals.
Foxy
Cale. He’s so good at every facet of the game
All hail Cale
Cale.
it’s makar by a trillion miles in my eyes
Karlsson for all time Makar for right now
makar. for the next 10 years the answer will be the same.
Duncan Keith 😎🤣
Makar and it’s not close. Expect a healthy and extremely motivated Avalanche squad this next season.
Jacob Slavin
Karlsson if we’re comparing each player during their prime.
Makar for right now only
“Get you outta my dreams get into Makar” – Billy Ocean
I say Erik Karlsson.
Snuck Matthew Tkachuk in there
Miro is lockdown
As a Stars fan, and someone relatively new to hockey, I know Miro is a star and one do the top players at his position. What makes Makar better or a lot better than him? Just curious.
And how would you rank Miro among defensemen and entire league?
Chuck Norris
Fox is underrated… but Makar still gets my vote.
Miro deserves some love too
Adam Fox
Really
really
The disrespect on Roman Josi is unreal rn. Dude had 96pts in 80Gms in the 2021/2022 season
Love Hughes but it’s Makar
Makar is just a notch above the pack. He’s elite at everything plus he’s super young, humble and hungry. His potential is the greatest of all time and he’s on pace to make it feasible.
Erik Karlsson.
Here in Makar, I feel safest of all. I can lock all my doors. It’s the only way to live, Makar.
Makar!
Makar but Hughes is underrated
No one hurt me, but shouldn’t Dahlin be in this conversation? Too young?
No love for Drew Doughty? WTF??!??
Jacob Slavin. Fucking Warrior.
Jaccob Slavin
Why tf is fox on this list?
The answer is obviously John Klingberg
Josi
Still crazy to me that Philly passed on Makar but I’m not a scout.
Makar
Not being hyperbolic but Makar is the 2nd best player in the league behind McDavid.
No Rasmussen Dahlin is just offensive.
Makar…. Karlsson is awesome when he’s not being a lazy ass. Played great this year hoping for a trade.
Makar by a mile. But maybe surprisingly for many, I’d take Heiskanen second out of this list. Kids a stud and actually knows how to defend aswell.
It has to be my favourite movie, “Dude Where’s Makar”
Seems to be a unanimous decision. Makar by a mile
Niklas Lidstrom. You don’t need the “When healthy” on that one btw.
Makar
Makar and it’s not close.
I don’t think anyone in this sub has actually watched Dahlin play