Jets STUN NFL With Geno Smith Trade?!
The Carton Show kicks off with chaos! Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle debate whether the New York Giants actually closed the gap with the Philadelphia Eagles after the first wave of NFL free agency. Are Giants fans getting ahead of themselves… or is the NFC East suddenly wide open?
Then things go completely off the rails when BREAKING NEWS hits the studio — the New York Jets have a new quarterback… Geno Smith?! Carton’s reaction says it all as he tries to figure out why the Jets would make this move and what it means for the franchise.
Plus:
-Are the Giants really a wild card contender in 2026?
-Why Big Mac is somehow excited about a punter
-Craig calls Boomer Esiason a “stat compiler” in classic WFAN fashion
Listen to the Carton Show Podcast!
Apple – https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-carton-show-with-craig-carton-chris-mcmonigle/id942553546
Spotify – https://open.spotify.com/show/38NxXo1DJoiKfpNaJC4YPR?si=7bbda5d1b2874e78
FOLLOW US:
TWITTER – https://twitter.com/WFAN660
INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/wfansportsradio/
FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/wfan660/
39 Comments
I liked carton with Boomer, a lil less with Evan, and now I really can't listen to him. Definitely the worst version of Craig yet
WORST FRANCHISE IN SPORTS HISTORY LOL 😆 JETS
The Giants can’t rely on Skat and Nabers being 100% healthy and they just lost Robinson.. The Giants problem for the last 10 years has been lack of big plays Tracy had 4 TDS last year .. The Giants better grab love at 5 or find a solid slot because that offense absolutely did not get better.. you will not win big games without someone to make big plays. I am a realistic giants fan .. The Giants have not a single person on their roster that can make someone miss or outrun someone .. Until u fix it you will have 5 win seasons ..
The Jets are going to tank next year. The goal is draft #1 overall next year, they won’t miss on manning, Geno took the Raiders to their QB last season, and he can do it again! Geno wins the draft pick bowl, every season.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I was a jets fan for over 40 years. I am officially done supporting the jets. They continue to make foolish moves and it is exhausting
Wait a minute, let me get this straight. The Raiders are getting Mendoza and we’re getting Geno Smith? Please tell me this is AI or a joke!
Giants should get Njoku or Dallas Goedert, price of WRs is too high. Put 3 weapon tight ends on the field if the cap makes it that way
Garbage announcer
lol Jets strike again! I’m sure Smith is going to be great in his return to NY.. after all, everything went so swimmingly last time, right? 🎉😂
This isn't that good
Geno will beg for his immediate release. He's earned enough money to not lower himself to put a Jets uniform on again. He'll retire first.
Does that mean Browning Nagle will be Geno's backup?
If you watch Gilliam punt I would be an improvement band I am 87 years old
It's the same ol Jets! Sing it Craig!
Geno's job in 2026 is to ensure a very high draft pick for the Jets in 2027. Plain and simple.
Take GW5 out of the question, what Jets player jersey are you buying? None of anything this year matters. Well over 50% of the roster won't be here 2 years from now. It's a tank season before the season has even started. Best case scenario, they go 2-15 get 1.1 in 2027, AG is fired, and finally and most importantly dumbdumb johnson hires a HC that's not a 1st time HC. Who the fu(k cares anymore? It's been a clown show for 40 years outside of 2010-2012. Who the fu(k cares anymore? There's kids learning to drive without having seen the Jets in the playoffs…🥳
No one wanted Wentz no one wanted Geno, just fn exhausting, what was the option exactly????
Haven’t had a punter since Weatherford.
PREDICTION: Carton returns to the MORNING DRIVE Show and reunites with Boomer Esaison‼️
🚬🙉🍌
I turn off the fan off daily from 2-6pm this guy is unbearable to listen to.
Hopefully a producer reads this and wakes up.
I'm a Raider fan and I feel bad for you. Goodluck in the new season.
Will stop watching all episodes and clips due to carton. Grade A loser
So we are basically getting Geno for the league minimum
16:20 what the title of the video talks about starts here 😂
I am so glad the Jets are tanking the season; fingers crossed for Manning in 2027. Las Vegas sent a 2025 third-round pick to Seattle and gave him a $75M two-year contract. Smith was so forgettable with his 17 INTs, the Raiders traded him and a 7th Rd pick to the Jets for a 6th Rd pick, and calling the trade a win.
This Carton guy is really irritating
Carton is annoying in every possible way. Get him off.
Carton is annoying in every possible way. Get him off.
Carton is racist and annoying
Geno was really good his last 3 years in Seattle. An upgrade to what they had last year. Who else where the Jets gonna get?😅😅
Who is a better option than Geno for 1.3 mil… cheaper to get him on the trade than open market money.
Cartons annoying af and constantly sounds like a casual lmfao harping on Genos time with the raiders as if he wasn’t dealing with the #32 o line in the league and ZERO wide receivers 😂😂😂😂😂 and before talkin hella shit should’ve waited and seen that the raiders are eating legit almost the entire contract
Craig is a national wfan treasure! 😂
Who's the drunk guy on the right?
Geno Smith? I give up, the season is over already.
Aaron judge is overrated
And Gino will do the mostJets thing ever. He's going to help you win just enough games to be out of the top 10 next year and make you use all of your assets to move up
16:12 Here for Craig Carton reaction 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂