Would you give up McDavid if it meant a guaranteed Stanley Cup?

13 Comments

1. 

   @dalriada 3 months ago

   The cup is the cup.

2. 

   @ClubberLang01 3 months ago

   I’d give up McDavid for a Stanley Cup in a heartbeat because we are most likely going to lose him for nothing next July anyways.

3. 

   @RudigerArbuckleIII 3 months ago

   Not tough at all. Cup is a cup.

4. 

   @deeshmond 3 months ago

   Easy decision. All I want to see is the Oilers win the cup. Keeping Connor is a bonus.

5. 

   Anonymous 3 months ago

   Not even a question

6. 

   @夏夢アイ 3 months ago

   All I want to see is Connor McDavid’s name under Edmonton Oilers written in the Stanley Cup and a photo of him hoisting the Stanley cup before he leaves.

7. 

   @WarrenSpears-q9r 3 months ago

   100 percent gone July 1

8. 

   @patrickleroux1355 3 months ago

   McDavid on Oilers is great 👍 Would love if he won a Cup with Edmonton.

   Two things I know for sure: No team has won a Cup with McDavid and many teams have won without McDavid.

   Prefer to get something rather nothing for 97.

9. 

   @UnhingedCanadian 3 months ago

   I care about the cup. Idc how we get there as long as we win a cup. Thats my honest opinion

10. 

    @TerryFoxs_leg 3 months ago

    NEVER! So at the same breath, you would be furious if MD answered that same question from his point of view. WTF guys!?

11. 

    @schematiks 3 months ago

    It’s not tough, Connor can go tomorrow for a Stanley…

12. 

    @Nunya_BizNess 3 months ago

    Who's Connor McDavid? Isn't he the guy who never wins the cup?

13. 

    @JurisDoctorDoom-2025 3 months ago

    Newsflash: Connor is gone July 1 AND there is no Cup for Edmonton. Fumbled a generational talent