Red no doubt. Red grew up in the west when it was still very much wild. In Landon Ricketts time. Marston had a possy to protect him for a while. Plus he was an outlaw. That means he wasnt looking for a fight when he was robbing someone. Marston has less shooting experience. Red however grew up by himself shooting and getting good with his gun. Harlow was also a better shot than john, and my evidence iis gameplay. If it came down to a fist fight, harlow still. He was half native. This matters because it made harlow taller, more muscular and more stocky.
The answer is obviously Red. In his game he was written to be basically bulletproof and put at such a high skill level that he would decimate armies of enemies without breaking a sweat (Mr. Black at ghost town). I love John and colton was cool. But legends never die for a reason
![Eli neufeld - minisampler [AMAZING] Triples etc.](https://www.lovenhl.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/1687280885_hqdefault-150x150.jpg)
40 Comments
John marston
i choise colton white
Red of course he's way more skilled
Iv'e thoroughly played through Red Dead Revolver, Gun and Red Dead Redemption… I choose John.
Only one of these guys has an heavily armored horse and a rotary cannon.
john the honorful cowboy that died by saving his own familly from dying or getting raped or worse
John Marston
Red Harlow is the best
Much obliged
John marston
Wil always be the best
John marston, OR….. aurthor morgan, tha new guy, if that dont count then john
Red no doubt. Red grew up in the west when it was still very much wild. In Landon Ricketts time. Marston had a possy to protect him for a while. Plus he was an outlaw. That means he wasnt looking for a fight when he was robbing someone. Marston has less shooting experience. Red however grew up by himself shooting and getting good with his gun. Harlow was also a better shot than john, and my evidence iis gameplay. If it came down to a fist fight, harlow still. He was half native. This matters because it made harlow taller, more muscular and more stocky.
I love John but Red is a complete BAD ASS tho!!!
None. Arthur Morgan! đ
john
Colton White. Becuase of his hartiage of Indian as well as his Lust for whats right & what isnt
Deadeye would be the best solution red Harlow
Red is the original he would win
Colton
Arthur Morgan
Arthur would wreck em all
The answer is obviously Red. In his game he was written to be basically bulletproof and put at such a high skill level that he would decimate armies of enemies without breaking a sweat (Mr. Black at ghost town). I love John and colton was cool. But legends never die for a reason
Uncle joins the fight LUMBAGO SMASH!!!
1. Tie between Red and Colton
2. Arthur
3. John
Arthur Morgan
John Would destroy
Who is Colton White?
John would get his ass kicked by both Red Harlow and Jack Swift!
Jack Swift
Arthur Morgan
Red had it rough more he watch his famliy get killed in front of him
What a fossil
Colton
Why do they have to fight why canât they be an unstoppable trio of bounty hunters
Colton White. Just a pissant kid with a six gun! đ
Colton White all the way baby
A sequel to gun would be crazy
Damn yall still not over this. smh
Big Smoke would ice these fools before he was even done with his order
Red isnât a âlegendary bounty hunterâ for no reason
i vote Colton dude