2025 NFL Draft Grades Round 1 – Josh Norris and Hayden Winks are live after the first round of the 2025 NFL Draft to go pick by pick and review each selection. How does Colston Loveland fit with the Bears? What about Matthew Golden and the Packers?
Hop on the Underdog app, hit the Big Board, grab some Player Pick’em. Promo Code: THESHOW
🐕 First Time Deposit Match On Underdog Fantasy: https://play.underdogfantasy.com/p-underedog-football-show
Must be 18+ (19+ in AL, NE; 19+ in CO for some games; 21+ in AZ & MA) and present in a state where Underdog Fantasy operates. Terms apply. Concerned with your play? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit www.ncpgambling.org; NY: Call the 24/7 HOPEline at 1-877-8-HOPENY or Text HOPENY (467369).
Subscribe to the Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-underdog-football-show/id1558961587
💬 Exclusive Giveaways and Promos! Join the Discord: ➡️ https://discord.gg/underdog
📈 Hayden’s Top 100 Prospects for 2025 NFL DRAFT:
https://underdognetwork.com/football/nfl-draft/2025-nfl-draft-top-100-prospects-hayden-winks-final-rankings
0:00 2025 NFL Draft Day 1 Reactions!
1:00 Tennessee Titans Select Cam Ward, QB
6:00 Jacksonville Jaguars Select Travis Hunter, WR/CB
15:23 New York Giants Select Abdul Carter, EDGE
19:30 New England Patriots Select Will Campbell, OT
24:00 Cleveland Browns Select Mason Graham, DT
30:36 Las Vegas Raiders Select Ashton Jeanty, RB
35:15 New York Jets Select Armand Membou, OT
37:25 Carolina Panthers Select Tet McMillan, WR
42:19 New Orleans Saints Select Kelvin Banks, OT
45:31 Chicago Bears Select Colston Loveland, TE
49:15 San Francisco 49ers Select Mykel Williams, EDGE
51:49 Dallas Cowboys Select Tyler Booker, OG
55:27 Miami Dolphins Select Kenneth Grant, DT
57:49 Indianapolis Colts Select Tyler Warren, TE
1:01:20 Atlanta Falcons Select Jalon Walker, EDGE
1:03:45 Arizona Cardinals Select Walter Nolen, DT
1:06:15 Cincinnati Bengals Select Shemar Stewart, EDGE
1:08:27 Seattle Seahawks Select Grey Zabel, OG
1:11:30 Tampa Bay Buccaneers Select Emeka Egbuka, WR
1:15:20 Denver Broncos Select Jahdae Barron, CB
1:17:54 Pittsburgh Steelers Select Derrick Harmon, DT
1:21:09 Los Angeles Chargers Select Omarion Hampton, RB
1:25:43 Green Bay Packers Select Matthew Golden, WR
1:30:01 Minnesota Vikings Select Donovan Jackson, OG
1:32:22 New York Giants TRADE and Select Jaxson Dart, QB
1:39:19 Atlanta Falcons TRADE and Select James Pearce Jr, EDGE
1:46:08 Baltimore Ravens Select Malaki Starks, S
1:48:32 Detroit Lions Select Tyleik Williams, DT
1:50:33 Washington Commanders Select Josh Conerly, OT
1:53:24 Buffalo Bills Select Maxwell Hairston, CB
1:55:52 Philadelphia Eagles Select Jihaad Campbell, LB
1:58:17 Kansas City Chiefs Select, Josh Simmons, OT
🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 https://streamyard.com/pal/d/5704423030652928
50 Comments
Love the broncos pick. One of the only 10-12 first round graded players at a premium position. Killer value
🦅!!!
The ads are insane holy shit
D grade for Hampton is wild. Najee is a slow low efficiency back. They have nobody else to run the ball. Hampton is not a luxury pick. Najee is fancy Gus Edwards at this point.
52:00 Hayden….🙄….Booker is one of the most highly rated o-linemen in all of college football playing against the highest level of competition. Just a dumb take, no other way to put it.
Jackson State isn't in Florida
If you guys weren’t fantasy guys the draft coverage would be so much better
You think Hunter will be a better WR than the Panthers?
They let any dumbass speak nowadays
Comments are crushing the guys but they gave my team an A so I have to say this was a fantastic video😂
😊🎉😊
These are some of the worst grades ive ever seen😭😭the ravens getting the top safety in the draft gives them a C?? Warren being a C+, dart being an A+??? clear rage bait
Yall have a fundamental misunderstanding of the colts. Ballard has drafted only ONE lineman in the first round and that was Nelson. He has built this line into various shades of good to elite from players ranging from the second round to 6 round. The colts are very very good at drafting lineman past the first round. Also 2) the NUMBER ONE need of the colts is for AR to develop. Ballard WILL be fired if that does not happen. A defender was never going to be this pick for that exact reason. That’s why I also think our second round pick will be a guard and then they will grab an RB later in the draft and a flyer lineman again even later in the draft
Regarding Pearce, we all did the same thing with Jalen Carter last season and he tore it up for the Eagles
Falcons will prove people wrong again
Eveyone is slumled on james pearce jr. people are gonna look back and wonder why he didnt go top 5.
The Packers drafting Golden, let's face it. It's a "luxury pick" that is also a GM/front office power play to make sure they have control over contracts not getting too big in the next few years and having the depth to "let go" of players through free agency. Matthew Golden is the equivalent of a college program bringing in a new Freshman who is going to be groomed to replace outgoing seniors. It's a "reload" pick and "future cap maintenance" pick. IMO, Golden doesn't add anything to the Packers WR room. Golden is a hybrid of Jayden Reed and Romeo Doubs. I think Golden's drafting will usher in the exit of Romeo Doubs via a trade in the next year.
mykel an A LMFAOOOOO, not to mention giving booker a D-… you mean the guy that didnt allow a single sack? foh
I sincerely question your football knowledge now.
Atl trade: giving up a 1st was too much but… you preach drafting as if you’re right, so isn’t this GM just trading picks as if he’s right? He’s betting that his team will perform well and that first round pick will be a late pick instead of a potential bad season and top 10 pick like you discussed..
Great show Guys! One pushback I have on the Atlanta Falcons and Rams trade is that I think you guys are overreacting a bit. The Rams gave up A TON THIS SEASON… it’s only good for the Rams next year, it’s almost like they’re punting this year. Are they giving up on Stafford? It’s not good for the morale in the locker room for this year….
C+ grade fur the Raiders is just stupid. They drafted the best player available and fulfilled their biggest need.
How does the Philadelphia trade make sense when they’re swapping? Were they worried that KC was gonna take their guy and if kc likeliked the same guy why would they make that trade? Seems like they gave up an extra pick for nothing.
Loveland as an A+ is a joke. He was drafted higher than Brock Bowers, lets see who has the better career
Yall are actually delusional. Ranking Jeanty and Hampton as poor picks is 🤡 activities. I’m unfollowing
Travis Hunter was a bad trade. He is not going to be worth those picks.
My lord what an ungodly amount of ads. Every 5 minutes. Usually love the content but getting hit with 15 ad breaks an hour and a half in is brutal.
Lack of real research. To say penix had “1 start” is wrong. He played 3 games and got 30+ppg in all of them. Falcons will be an over .500 team with low difficulty, and they are crapping on the trade up because they think that falcons first next year will be high, which it just won’t
This guy says take the best available player during fantasy drafts but complain when a actual NFL team doest it. Like bruhhh
*Maxwell Hairston was CB3 taken in the draft*. Barron was CB2, betting apps had Travis Hunter listed at CB just like he was at the combine. The Browns and Giants first selection being either CB or DLine/Edge were all favorites by a large margin.
Disagree about Hampton being a luxury pick. The Chargers haven't had a reliable RB2 in Herbert's career. Adding a durable 220lb. 3-down RB that can catch and pass protect in a Greg Roman offense constructed to run first means Hampton will receive 3x+ the touches a WR would have while learning the ropes from Najee. Charger fans will appreciate having Omarion/Najee backfield come the playoffs.
Plus, Jim Harbaugh still hasn't seen Justin Herbert with a run game.
So… forgot to grade the 1st 3 picks, then fix it only to forget to grade the Patriots 4th pick 🤔😆
Lol. I don't know why we watch beautiful athletes perform in college every year only to hear dweeb ass white boys pan the very same guys. These 2 jock sniffers just said the Falcons were ludicrous for last 2 yrs taking Michael Penix and this the 2! Arguably best pass rushers in the SEC lol. The Falcons swapped! 1st rounders and in exchange moved down from the second to the 3rd. These dudes will have you believe they gave up qb draft capital. Don't listen to basement dweebs who never put on a uniform of any kind. Neither of them even look like athletic table tennis players lol. But their experts on NFL personnel 😂😂😂. Got a bride in South Dakota for u
Kelvin Banks Jr. will play Left Tackle as rookie. Taliese Fuaga will go to Right Tackle. Trevor Penning played left tackle in college and will be moved to Left Guard on a you have 1 year to prove it to us 4th year this season to get a new contract next season.
This comes from Bobby Herbert and Deuce McAllister on the Saints Radio network last night.
Fuaga played right tackle in college naturally. Banks played Left tackle every snap he started at Texas. Fuaga will not stay at Left tackle
How is trading a 1st for a 1st and a 2-3 pick swap crazy value? Please someone explain it to me. NFL "analysts" are sheep.
They drafted beasley in 2015 and he had 15.5 one season but ya not much in the pass rush dept
I do not mean to be all up in your grills like the diehard Saints fan that I am, but the Saints do have an option at qb. His name is Spencer Rattler.
Spencer Rattler played amazing in the last game of the year against the buccs with 2nd and 3rd team players starting all over the offense due to injury and had 3 wide receivers who were on other teams practice squads 5 weeks earlier to throw to and he uplifted and made the offense sing until the OC who is not here anymore would not change or adjust his gameplan to account for the defensive changes at halftime done by the buccs.
Klint kubiak went ahead with the same calls and approach in the 2nd half and the buccs defense stopped the offense in the 2nd half.
Spencer Rattler would've been the 1st or 2nd qb taken this year, that's how good his talent, arm talent, character, and competitiveness have been since he has been here.
Shadeur wouldn't beat him out neither would Dart.
Rattler was a fifth round Steal.
If given the chance to compete for the starting spot bc of Carr's shoulder, he will prove he is the man.
A+ for Dart?
Sanders to the raiders calling it!
1:11:29 pause
As a lifelong Carolina Panthers fan this was my #1 wish pick of this draft class… wow. Merry. Effing Christmas bro Josh! As a Jake DelHomme 93' until Infinity fan I'm so happy for you and me
Let's GOOOOOO
C+ for Ashton Jeanty is fucking comical, raiders never get love. Just like when they took bowers. Raiders had no RB last year and still had very good RB Grades. Go check the O Lines final 6 games ranking.
Love you guys. Elite content. Thank you.
Y’all hatin bad on atl🤣🤣 dgaf abt that late ass 1st it’s gonna be
No browns or Patriots grade?
d thats your grade
Good insight. Your time stamps for the video have like a minute overlap from the previous picks, could be cleaner.
a D for the Charegers ? Who the hell are you ? Your a nobody ! The Chargers have 10 picks in the draft ! Theres nothing wrong with the Chargers Wide Receivers. Quinton Johson had a good your year last year , they got Mike Williams back. Harbaugh likes to run the football down your throat . Your a looser !
What drugs are you taking where booker is a D-?
CBS Sports > than these tools and their platform ridiculous skewed towards WR.
Hayden probably still pushing Kyle Pitts in Round 2