Cale Makar is signed until 2027 for $9m. I do not care about future cap increases, Noah Dobson isn't 50% of the play that Cale is, and yes I know he took a huge discount. I do not want to lock in that Noah is our #1 guy, he just isn't. If he was, our powerplay wouldn't be dead last and historically horrific.
No. Trade him. We should do everything humanly possible to draft Matthew Schaeffer. Champions are built around defense. Schaeffer is the most talented defensemen in have seen in awhile.
I believe that Dobson is a 50-55 pt defenseman who is C- defensively who does not consistently make the Outlet Pass or Rush the Puck up the ice and who is C- as the QB of the PP.
Who gives a rats ass. No commitment to winning here. Worst season in 30 yrs. Why? Because this was to be the rebuild. And we got Duclair. A guy who's always hurt. Played on a dozen teams. Big embarrassing joke since day 1 of the season. Give it up for lent.
Breaking news fellow islander fans, reports just in nelson and palmieri being shopped! Aka both will be traded! Teams interested la kings,Winnipeg, toronto,dallas,and Detroit. P.s. yes trade dobson asap.
15 Comments
Cale Makar is signed until 2027 for $9m. I do not care about future cap increases, Noah Dobson isn't 50% of the play that Cale is, and yes I know he took a huge discount. I do not want to lock in that Noah is our #1 guy, he just isn't. If he was, our powerplay wouldn't be dead last and historically horrific.
Romanov should be more of a priority. He has proven that he is a complete dman.
Trading Dobson is the best way to secure the top line forward this team badly needs to add.
No. Trade him. We should do everything humanly possible to draft Matthew Schaeffer. Champions are built around defense. Schaeffer is the most talented defensemen in have seen in awhile.
I believe that Dobson is a 50-55 pt defenseman who is C- defensively who does not consistently make the Outlet Pass or Rush the Puck up the ice and who is C- as the QB of the PP.
That doesn't sound like a 9 million player.
Trade. Soft as a marshmallow and weak in the defensive zone.
If we get these players out and get younger, faster, more skilled, i think Noah could thrive in a more offensive team.
Who gives a rats ass. No commitment to winning here. Worst season in 30 yrs. Why? Because this was to be the rebuild. And we got Duclair. A guy who's always hurt. Played on a dozen teams. Big embarrassing joke since day 1 of the season. Give it up for lent.
Breaking news fellow islander fans, reports just in nelson and palmieri being shopped! Aka both will be traded! Teams interested la kings,Winnipeg, toronto,dallas,and Detroit. P.s. yes trade dobson asap.
Dobson sucks
Trade Obson !!
send him to the moon!
Wait wait what hole would you be talking about he is the hole right now
Trade him
I think it just depends on what Lou could get for him. I wouldn’t trade him just to trade him.