The WORST NFL Quarterback in Every Season of the 2010s
Who was the worst NFL quarterback in every season of the 2010s? From brutal interceptions to jaw-dropping mistakes, this video takes a deep dive into the quarterbacks who struggled the most during each NFL season from 2010 to 2019. Whether you’re a diehard football fan or just enjoy reliving the highs and lows of NFL history, this video is for you.
We’ll analyze infamous performances from quarterbacks like Jared Goff, Peyton Manning, and more as we break down their worst moments. From busted draft picks to failed veterans, these are the players who couldn’t get it done under center. Did your team have one of the worst quarterbacks of the 2010s?
This video is packed with NFL history, including stats, highlights, and memorable (or forgettable) moments that showcase why these QBs struggled so much. Perfect for fans of NFL analysis, sports debates, and ranking the best and worst in football.
If you love NFL content about bad quarterbacks, epic failures, and the most shocking moments in football, hit play now and relive a decade of quarterback misery. Don’t forget to like, comment, and subscribe for more football history and NFL breakdowns.
#nfl #nflfootball #quarterbacks
Intro 0:00
Jimmy Clausen 0:35
Blaine Gabbert 3:29
Mark Sanchez 6:52
Geno Smith 10:27
Blake Bortles 13:43
Peyton Manning 17:17
Jared Goff 21:17
DeShone Kizer 24:23
Josh Rosen 27:47
Dwayne Haskins 30:38
Music by Karl Casey @ White Bat Audio
X: https://x.com/KaiTheBeachKid
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@kaithebeachkid
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/kaithebeachkid/
45 Comments
I feel a Gabert style player is coming to the Saints this 2025
Awesome vid
With as bad as the Tampa Bay Buccaneers were from 2010-2019 including 7 last place division finishes, 5 seasons of 5 wins or less, and only 1 double digit win season in that span I find it hard to believe not one of their quarterbacks made this list.
11 years later and Geno Smith is still bad
Will levis make them look like tom brady
It’s rough being a jags fan 😢
Rip Dwayne Haskins
I wanted Gabbert as a Vikings fan because I thought he was gonna be him.
Rosen was not the right choice to put on this list. He didn't do horrible with his situation. Cardinals did him dirty
How dare you bring up Dwayne Haskins up in a bad quarterback video. Leave that man and his peace alone. Fuck is wrong with you
Crazy Ponder didn't make it
17:17 What happens when you're finally off your PEDs. 😂
Comparing Geno and Goff is a bad comparison since you're implying Goff didn't shine until he went to Detroit, as if the Rams failed him. Goff was a good but not great QB with the Rams. He took them to a SB. Geno, on the other hand, showed NOTHING until he went to Seattle.
mark wasnt the worse in 2012 vick and chad henne wasnt no better and geno wasnt what about mike glennon this a all out attack against the jets 😭
Why is every entry not Andy Dalton after 8 PM?
Broncos only won sb50 bc Peyton announced his retirement at the last second before the Super Bowl so of course the nfl going to pay off the game to give that last name another sb win and screw cam Newton and the panthers that would’ve ran over the broncos with our number 1 offense and defense and idc what this dude said about the broncos having the number 1 defense the panthers had the number 1 defense that year if they wasn’t paid off to lose and in my opinion Eli and Peyton don’t deserve no hall of fame they are average qbs both throw wobbly balls like Tim Tebow and they were lucky to have decent receivers that can catch to make them look good same going to happen with arch manning in the future and I’m hoping he gets shut down in college and no nfl team wants him bc we don’t need another sucky manning in the nfl that gets free wins bc of the last name
Cody Kessler slander will not be tolerated 😡
Geno smith shouldn't be on the list when he still playing qb and got aloy better witha better team
"His rookie season serves as an example of why NFL teams are hesitant to throw rookie quarterbacks into the fire with such a lackluster Supporting Cast in today's NFL"
Man, if only someone told today's NFL this example, I don't think any of the following teams got that picture with their current or just recently dropped players: Bills, Jets (twice even), Dolphins, Patriots (maybe twice), Jaguars, Bengals, Broncos, Cardinals maybe? (You mentioned Fitz being on the older side with Rosen and he was Kyler's best target in his rookie season), Panthers, Commanders, and the Giants (who may do the same to their next QB as well, considering Nabers is the only worthwhile target as of right now).
For those that may look at a few of these options and think that they are not busts like Gabbert was in Jacksonville, I bring you the exact quote of lackluster supporting cast and thrown into the fire in their rookie season. We have things like Josh Allen's offensive weapons were a 30 year old Shady (who Allen had more rushing yards than that season) and his best target was Zay Jones. And say like the Commanders where Jayden Daniels' best target is… Well, the same best target Dwayne Haskins had, but older. We could also add the Bears on this list for Fields but not Caleb Williams, which is why I didn't list them since clearly they tried to set up Caleb to succeed… emphasis on tried, but they did give him a good supporting cast. Maybe I missed someone, but there are a lot of teams that don't qualify. Like Packers or Raiders who didn't have great WR cores when their young QBs took the helm, but they weren't thrown into the fire in their Rookie Season. AoC and Love weren't the starting QBs, they were drafted to sit and learn.
Lmao. Peyton Manning was so good that his last season he was just an average QB and this guy thinks he was the WORST in the league 💀
I never noticed just how pitiful Mannings arms looked in that final season
I think Blaine Gabbert got a SB ring with the bucs
Oh Sanchez shit had me laughing every year
Played a flag football game against Jimmy Clausens team in the 7th grade. He… Er… Beat us. Lets leave it at that. We had a good team too. Our QB got a scholarship to USC in the Pete Carroll days and got into a few games. But man…
Matt Cassel is older than me but I was in T-ball at the same Little League as him when he was on the team that won the Little League World Series.
I left after you said “Steve smith was end of his prime” WTF are you talking about 😭😭😭😭😭
All those years for Manning where he put up all time numbers and had all time offenses but was let down by his defense… His last year were just things evening out. That said the Manning glaze in the comments is crazy. He was TERRIBLE that year. Its fine. Mannings great. He was hurt. But they did not win the Superbowl because of him. I dont want to hear about intangibles. If any other QB put up those numbers youd say he was carried. That he had the worst season of any QB to win it all. And of course throw in some arbitrary Brady hate… "Brady had good defenses as well…"
When did Brady ever have a season any where near as bad as Mannings last year? Its laughable…
Jamis Winston should be up there
also how many tipped passes you gonna show?
not putting zack wilson is crazy
The Geno Smith disrespectf is crazy
👎👎❌❌❌🗑️🗑️👎👎👎👎
Jets are just a bad franchise. Lets see Geno Smith is doing good now and Sam Darnold is going strong. What a coincidence two draft picks by the JETS.
Classy flemlo not shitting on Travis, love this guy 💪
Was anyone elses main takeaway to avoid signing Steven Hill at all costs or just me
Blake bortles had the greatest garbage time fantasy season ever.
“The Corpse of Santonio Holmes” 💀
Deshone Kizer may be the worst trade Green Bay ever made. We gave up a starting defensive back for him and he never scored a single point in the regular season or playoffs for us.
Some Players and their Super Bowl performances. Both Super Bowls
Payton Manning won were not because he played so well in the big game. Leading into the Super Bowl against the Bears, Manning did have a good performance erasing a 21-3 Patriot first haf lead. Payton Manning was known for his lazer focus. A mind for the game and an arm to go with it. These attributes had very little to do with his second Super Bowl win. His skills had eroded through injury and father time, who is undefeated. On the other hand, brother Ely won the big game twice, and both were because of his outstanding performances. It makes me wonder if Payton feels awkward about how he played. He shouldn't, especially his first Super Bowl. In the 2007 Super Bowl he was 25 for 38, 247 yards, one TD, and one INT. There is nothing wrong with that stat line unless you are Payton and usually throws for over 300 yards and multiple TDs. In his second Super Bowl, he once again threw for 1 TD and 1 INT. it was his 141 yards passing that was so unfamiliar. CJ Anderson made up the difference rushing for 90 yards on 23 carries. The games MVP wasn't even from the offensive side of the ball. Von Miller led the Broncos defense from his edge position. He compiled 6 tackles 2 batted passes, 2.5 sacs, 2 QB hits, and two forced fumbles in a defensive game for the ages. Miller is built like a Greek god at 6ft3, 250lbs. A man who is not afraid to tuck his shirt in. Coming out of college he ran a lightning quick 4.42 seconds in the 40-yard dash. He used every bit of his frame and speed to turn in one of, if not the best, defensive effort and stat line ever recorded in a Super Bowl. As a side note, Von Miller is back on the field after serving a 4 game suspension. Miller recorded a sack in Buffalo's thumping of the NY Jets last weekend. Miller was upto his normal business helping the Rams win Super Bowl 56. He had two recorded sacs and was a defensive stud along with Aaron Donald helping LA pull out a narrow victory over Joe Burrows and the Cincinnati Bengals. Rested and refreshed Miller is hoping to be a big reason why the Buffalo Bill's may win their first Super Bowl. A possible Cinderella story this year is the Minnesota Vikings QB and clear leader Sam Darnold. Darnold and his Vikes face another feel good story in the perennial lovers the Detroit Lions and Jared Goff in the final game of the 2024 regular season. The winner of this game will be the NFC number 1 seed and hole field advantage in their run for the Super Bowl. Eam Darnold who was considered in New York as a complete bust has thrown for 35 TDs and led the Vikings to a 14-2 record. They face another cast off in Jared Goff. Even though Goff led the LA Rams to the 2019 Super Bowl losing to the Patriots 12-3 he was blamed for the loss and considered not a good enough signal caller to win the big game. Such a loser that the Rams traded him plus their first and third round draft picks to the Lions for Gun slinger Mathew Stafford. The trade looked like a steal for the Rams winning the Super Bowl the very next year. While Goff went 3 wins 13 loses. Don't forget Goff was playing for the Detroit Lions who a few years earlier had gone 0-16. In Goff's second year 2022 the Lions started off 1-6 but finished the season with a9-8 record. The Rams missed the playoffs in the 2022 season. Both teams did better in 2023 the Lions 12-5 the Rams 10-7. The lions met the Rams in Detroit as a part of the NFC wild card weekend. This was Mathew Staffords first game back in Detroit since the trade from the team he played his first 12 years for. The Lions won narrowly eliminating the Rams. Detroit made it to the NFC championship losing to the 49ers due largely to two dropped passes. The trade still clearly favors the Rans with the Super Bowl win, but it is evening out. So the was bust Sam Darnold against the scape goat Jared Goff this Sunday night. Detroit really needs this bye weekend as they have had a pandemic of injuries all on the defensive side of the ball. If they can secure the bye they are expected to get back upto 4 defensive players for what would earn their first playoff game of 2024. The lions have been missing 21 players from their defensive unit.
Manning in the thumbnail is crazy work!
9 TDs to 17 picks would have gotten anybody else packed up immediately 😂
The butt fumble will never not be funny😂
Wasn’t the Kizer season the year that got them Baker, not Garrett?
I think we can all agree that Peyton Manning is the worst out of all of these fine candidates presented.
Per ESPN, after his draft, Deshone Kizer called himself a mix of Tom Brady's mind and Cam Newton's body, and says he has the ability to be "the greatest quarterback to ever play."
He also said, "No one else can do what I do," technically, he was right.
Jags still have Gabbert pretty much