Mastodon
@Toronto Maple Leafs

Who is the most underrated Leaf player of all time?



Who is the most underrated Leaf player of all time?

by RivetCounter

42 Comments

  1. BlueLeafs

    I can’t wait to see where we put Phil Kessel.

  2. ZeusDaMongoose

    Kaberle 1000%. “He doesn’t shoot enough”, “He doesn’t hit enough” , “He’s too soft”, “He’s too European”, “His cheeks are too rosy” “McCabe is better”

    It was sickening to listen to all the BS about this guy. Kaberle was elite AF.

  3. chiefjackmehoff

    Rick Vaive. First leaf to ever hit 50 goals, and did it back to back to back (3 years straight).

  4. Hectordoink

    Hall of Famer Larry Murphy — 4 cups (two after he left), six all-star teams. We booed the shit out of him for his two seasons here and chased him out of his home town.

  5. Hirtle_41

    I like the Kaberle answer. I like the Kessel answer. I would also make a historical case for Ed Olczyk.

  6. Iliketothrowaway2456

    Kaberle.

    Gardiner is too.. man was a very good defenseman for us, but the ghosts of Boston ruined him and his reputation here.

    Ed Belfour as well. People were so pissed when Cujo left but the reality is that before the Lockout, Belfour was a top 5 goalie in the league for us. But most people were mad that he struggled adapting badly in the year after the lockout

  7. 123jazzhandz321

    Immediately my mind went to Clarke McArthur

  8. highnoon222

    Dave Anderchyuk. I never hear anyone talk about him amongst the 90s Leafs greats.

    2 time 50 goals scorer while with TO.
    Lead league in PP goals while with TO.
    7th all time Leafs record: most points in a season.

  9. YourStarsAlgonquin

    Alan Bester would be HOF if he didn’t have the dogshit 80s Leafs infront of him.

    kid’s “seen more rubber then (sic) a dead skunk on the Trans Canada Highway” D. Cherry

  10. alldawgsgoat2heaven

    Shocked I’m the first to say Mike Gartner…

Write A Comment